This webpage was prepared for MA595-2015 by Eliana M. Duarte Rigidity of Frameworks

Rigidity of Quasicrystal Frameworks

IGL team: Chong Han, Alec Mori, Dan Pugliese, Joe Zeller, Zach Miksis
Mentors: Eliana Duarte, George Francis
(C) 2014, Illinois Geometry Laboratory, University of Illinois

Introduction to rigidity of frameworks in 2D

A framework in 2D consists of a set of edges in the Eucliden plane that are joined at vertices. For our puporses, all of the edges have a fixed length but the angle at the vertex of a joint is allowed to change. Consider a framework that consists of just 3 edges which are joined to form a triangle. It is easy to see that this framework is rigid, the triangle won't change its shape. However if we consider a framework with four edges forming a square, we see that the angles at the joints of the framework may change freely.

For this project we will consider frameworks that come from a piece of a Penrose tiling. We refer to any such framework as a Penrose framework. Penrose tilings are made out of two types of rhombi, a skinny one and a fat one. A face(i.e a rhombus) in the framework can be made rigid by not allowing the angles at the joints to change and by fixing them to be the angles of a fat or skinny rhombus. We will refer to the operation of rigidifying a face of the framework as bracing the face. If the framework has no braced faces, it can move freely and all of the faces can change their shapes. If we brace all the faces of the framework then the only possible motion of the framework is a rotation as a whole body. What would happen if we only brace certain faces? Will the framework be rigid? This is excatly the questions we are intersed in discussing throughout this project. More precisely:

For a given Penrose framework in 2D how many and which faces should I brace to make the framework rigid?

Here is a short video explaining the rigidity problem for 2D Penrose frameworks.

Modeling rigidity with physical frameworks

One way to model the rigidity problem for 2D frameworks is to build the frameworks by using rods and joining them at the vertices in such a way that the angle at a joint may change. For this project we will present how to build acrylic frameworks by using a laser cutter to make the rods and screws to join them at the vertices. All you need to do is to follow closely the detailed instructions found at the Framework factory.
The end result will look like the following framework: Test Image
To get ideas of how to start studying and understanding the rigidity problem you can go to the Rigidity Lab .

Modeling rigidity with Real Time Interactive Animations (RTICAs)

Another way to model the rigidity problem is to use RTICA's. There are many advantages in the use of RTICA's. For instance, using a computer you are able to consider bigger frameworks. Additionally, thinking about how to model the problem in a computer might give interesting insight on how to solve the rigidity problem for 2D Penrose frameworks.

The punch line

If you want to find out how to decide if a braced Penrose framework is rigid you can experiment with this version of the Wester Game. Or read our paper here .